Fizzle

Bird Dog's picture

Amitai Etzioni summarizes it well:

Given that Occupy Wall Street has not advocated any specific ways to reduce inequality and does not have the political organization to back up such an agenda, either others will have to find ways to curb inequality or we will see little progress on this front in the great budget battles to come shortly after the 2012 election.

Most assuredly, a general strike that fizzles will not serve the cause of reducing inequality, or even help Occupy Wall Street find its sea legs. Occupy Wall Street will have more opportunities to show that it did not flame out; however, it had better come up with a more cogent strategy, or it will soon be one more wasted force, one more protest movement that vented feelings but engendered precious little real social change.

To me, another problem is the movement's anarchist roots. If they can't create a consistent message, then others will step in and do it for them. Another problem is with the anarchists in the movement such as Brandon "Skabby" Baxter and the idiots in Seattle and San Francisco and Oakland. By the way, at Dan "you pansy asses" Savage's magazine, where he is editorial director, one of the writers defended the violent acts against property at the Seattle May Day gatherings and elsewhere, while at the same time saying he is not a proponent of same. You see, breaking windows and other things at businesses isn't violence, it's vandalism, so it's all good. Anyway, the Dark Knight has weighed in...

 

 

...and he's nonplussed. Same with the Village Voice:

We witnessed several of Tuesday's May Day festivities. While not everyone involved in the demonstrations were "bums" (which we pointed out in a post yesterday), the media's take doesn't seem to be too far off -- it's hard to take many of these people seriously when they're biting cops, dumping buckets of feces in public places, and strolling around New York in Halloween costumes.

As Susan Ostrowski, a 55-year-old woman who works at a Wall Street insurance company, suggests, it seems some of the occupiers would be better served by "find[ing] jobs and protest[ing] on their time off. They should get involved politically, register to vote rather than sitting and sleeping on the steps in sleeping bags."

As we mentioned yesterday, not all of the occupiers are unemployed hobos. Unfortunately, the non-unemployed hobos involved with Occupy Wall Street get lumped in with the "bums" because the "bums" and their antics get the most ink in the press.

Fizzle.

 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Occupy Wall Street...remind me again

(#280178)

is that that movement that more or less single-handedly pinched off the oxygen tube to whatever right wing assassination campaign was underway at the time and got most of the country and the media to refocus on economic inequality? Those guys?

M Aurelius was probably right.

Um, Huh?

(#280180)
M Scott Eiland's picture

You might want to have the Sniper Grandmas work on their note taking techniques, because the first part of that sentence is utterly baffling and--given the Occupy ties of the loon who just killed four people down near the border--outright laughable on the merits.

The universe may well have been created without a point--that doesn't imply that we can't give it one.

It seems I accidentally a word.

(#280182)

"Right wing character assassination campaign" that was supposed to've read. You know, digging up dirt on people with policies you don't like, then flooding every media channel with that crap in lieu discussing policy? Right wing "news"? I'm sure you're familiar with it.

 

The Occupy people got the country talking about stuff like mortgages, investment fraud, bailouts and so forth, for a little while at least. Yep, they really blew the foam off Matt Drudge's hate mocha there for a few weeks.

 

I'm impressed.

M Aurelius was probably right.

I am impressed too

(#280570)

But it's perfectly legitimate to ask if OWS will turn out to be a one trick pony. They have a tough problem to solve. Follow-through is hard, and Wall Street is a slippery, adaptable target.

I am not a pessimist. I am an incompetent optimist.

There's a long, hot summer ahead

(#280185)
HankP's picture

I wouldn't be so quick to draw conclusions in May.

I blame it all on the Internet

Early days

(#280187)

Eventually, economic problems become political problems. This is one of the first distinct movements that keys off the problem of economic inequality. It will become different, and more coherent, by and by.

 

One could argue, of course, that the Tea Party is simply the mirror image of OWS. Many Tea Partiers feel economically left behind as well. They just blame the government.

They couldn't hit an elephant at this dist...
-- General John B. Sedgwick, 1864

The general strike didn't do much

(#280209)

But I don't think of that as a "fizzle" since a general strike was a giant stretch. 

 

So far they've been gathering media attention through small-scale protests. They received F-P reporting on many media sites on May Day, so I don't see this as a fizzle so much as a setback. A fizzle would be if nobody turned out to their protests, but that didn't happen.