Elitism


Ta-Nahesi Coates just defined it for all time. Since it would be impossible to excerpt his excellent piece and retain the sense of it, click the link. I'll add my thoughts.

"Elitism" is the charge leveled by rural whites against those who disdain their culture of grievance. I was frankly surprised that a man of Coates' background can understand this as clearly as he does, but perhaps it is not so surprising after all: he lived in Marion Barry's Washington, and the forces that drove Barry's candidacy are the same as those driving Sarah Palin's (and James Inhofe's, and half the School Board candidates of my tiny West Virginia home town, and any number of others). When a population feels persecuted, the key aspect of political appeal is not whether the politician is competent, honest, or qualified, but whether he is One Of Us. Cultures of grievance have a standard that is simple and binary.

Rural whites are never accused of this in public, but they have been nurturing such a culture for at least two generations. All the elements are present. There's the mythologizing of history: Palin's comment that "If the Pledge was good enough for the Founding Fathers, it's good enough for me" and the insistence by white evangelicals, in the face of all evidence, that the United States was founded on the Christian faith. There are the demands of redress for their suffering -- yep, the biggest beneficiaries of federal money are overwhelmingly red states with high populations of rural whites (21 of the top 25). There is the culture of honor, where machismo is highly prized (Tim Wise, in a piece linked by Coates, strikingly compares Bristol Palin's boyfriend with a gangsta rapper).

And, of course, the central definition of cultures of grievance is that they live in a constant state of affront. They revel in it, in fact. No one can read the exultant screeds penned this campaign season -- dealing with everything from Obama's bowling score, to his ill-considered (if quite accurate) "bitter" remarks, to the laughably manufactured "sexism" of his lipstick-on-a-pig comment and the beyond-ridiculous arugula flap -- without such revelry staring them right in the face.

So what is elitism? It's nothing at all. The charge of "elitism" is something: it is an expression of identity politics. The taboos Obama has broken are the taboos of white rural political-correctness. If any final proof of this were needed, consider that Sarah Palin's acceptance speech quoted Westbrook Pegler. The quote read "We grow good people in our small towns, with honesty and sincerity and dignity." Innocuous enough; but who's Westbrook Pegler?

He's the guy who also wrote this, of Robert F. Kennedy: "[I] hope some white patriot of the Southern tier will spatter his spoonful of brains in public premises before the snow flies."
--

The other day I heard that ignorance and apathy are sweeping the country. I didn't know that, but I don't really care.

--

The other day I heard that ignorance and apathy are sweeping the country. I didn't know that, but I don't really care.

--

The other day I heard that ignorance and apathy are sweeping the country. I didn't know that, but I don't really care.

--

The other day I heard that ignorance and apathy are sweeping the country. I didn't know that, but I don't really care.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Now this is sorta funny... (#121418)
by Davinci

But a lot of news outlets seem to be taking this pretty seriously, so it's probably worth taking a closer look.

Lynn Forester de Rothschild, a prominent Hillary Clinton supporter and member of the Democratic National Committee's Platform Committee, will endorse John McCain for president on Wednesday, her spokesman tells CNN.

The announcement will take place at a news conference on Capitol Hill, just blocks away from the DNC headquarters. Forester will "campaign and help him through the election," the spokesman said of her plans to help the Republican presidential nominee.

Explaining her distaste for Obama, Forester said, "I feel like he is an elitist."

Let me get this straight. Lynn Forester de Rothschild, who tends to go by "Lady Lynn Forester de Rothschild," is the CEO of an international holding company. She's married to Sir Evelyn de Rothschild, a British financier and a member of the prominent Rothschild banking family of England. She splits her time living in London and New York.

And she's backing John McCain, a multimillionaire who has lost track of how many homes he owns, because she perceives Obama as "an elitist."

http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/archives/individual/2008_09/014764.php

--

Ask courageous questions. Do not be satisfied with superficial answers. Be open to wonder and at the same time subject all claims to knowledge, without exception, to intense skeptical scrutiny. Be aware of human fallibility. Cherish your species and your

As Michael Kinsley put it (#121425)
by Brooks and B Ra...

As Michael Kinsley put it last July:

if they go off in a snit when their candidate loses the nomination, that will suggest that they aren't really in this out of progressive passion--they just find politics an amusing hobby, like racehorses or yachts. http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1821662,00.html

sig weirdness - Hank? (#121378)
by stillnotking

I haven't edited this entry at all since posting it, but my sig is still replicated 3 times. Just thought I'd let you know; I don't care, myself, but others have mentioned they find it annoying.

--

The other day I heard that ignorance and apathy are sweeping the country. I didn't know that, but I don't really care.

"Elitism" is the charge (#121296)
by Brooks and B Ra...

"Elitism" is the charge leveled by rural whites against those who disdain their culture of grievance.

Hmm, as long as we're generalizing and classifying whole groups in pejorative terms, should rural whites and urban blacks unite under a newly formed "Culture Of Grievance" Party? The COG Party name does lend itself to some neat slogans, like: "COGs against the machine!"

That'd be awesome (#121379)
by stillnotking

Unfortunately a good fraction of the pejorative terms of those two groups are reserved for one another, so it probably wouldn't work.

--

The other day I heard that ignorance and apathy are sweeping the country. I didn't know that, but I don't really care.

Exactly right (#121260)
by Floater

As someone who grew up in a tiny town I agree with this 100%. I had been thinking about writing a diary on the subject myself but this describe it up quite well.

"nurturing such a culture for at least two generations" (#121230)
by HankP

You're kidding, right? The South has been nurturing it for 140 years. Gone With the Wind was published 72 years ago and is 93 years old. This victimization has proven quite resistant to logic or the passage of time, so I wouldn't get your hopes up about it getting resolved anytime soon.

--

I blame it all on the Internet

Its a normal facet of humanity. (#121337)
by mmghosh

Over here, for example, some of the population whose numbers actually constitute 83% of the nation considers itself "victimised" and threatened by a tiny number of people who change their religion.

A report by the Delhi-based rights body said thousands of Christians had fled their villages and some 5,000 were living at seven relief camps at Chakapad, Tikabali, G. Udaygiri, Raikia, Baliguda, K. Nuagaon and Phiringia.

About 200 villages, it added, were affected by the “organised attacks and hundreds of churches, including house churches, have been burnt”.

900 million people should not be so insecure that the attack (#121373)
by Davinci

others religious views. I have said along time that the true war in the world is between the forces of tolerance and intolerance or change and stasis.

Conversion is a form of violence who is that nut?

--

Ask courageous questions. Do not be satisfied with superficial answers. Be open to wonder and at the same time subject all claims to knowledge, without exception, to intense skeptical scrutiny. Be aware of human fallibility. Cherish your species and your

Evangelism and conversions are dicey issues. (#121374)
by mmghosh

Evangelism is always controversial, in the sense that Christianity is associated with the west and rich Americans (as is Islam and rich Saudis). In addition, there is the problem that our population of Hindu low castes and outcastes are being positively discriminated in terms of education and employment - but conversion leads to a loss of these benefits. A low caste Christian convert therefore would be entitled to an education in a Christian school and an entitled IIT education after that.

The culture of entitlements, claims and counterclaims largely obscure the religion issue. Over here, conversion is not just a matter of a personal, private decision.

Now that is a dairy waiting to be read mmghosh (#121376)
by Davinci

It would be interesting to have one on a system that I do not understand and find hard to grasp... The caste system is as foreign as it get IMHO. Sometime if it interests you I would love you to fill out the topic you hit on. We tend to view a lot of issues in straight religious terms because it is easy etc. (Lazy on our part)..

Have a good week....
Da

--

Ask courageous questions. Do not be satisfied with superficial answers. Be open to wonder and at the same time subject all claims to knowledge, without exception, to intense skeptical scrutiny. Be aware of human fallibility. Cherish your species and your

A caste system is hard to handle? (#121407)
by mmghosh

Every culture has it. And yes I will come up with diary on religion, evangelism and my opposition thereto.

I erred on the side of caution (#121238)
by stillnotking

Also, I think there's a lot more at work than racism per se, and the culture of grievance is not confined to the South. If anything, it's probably more prevalent in the Midwest these days.

--

The other day I heard that ignorance and apathy are sweeping the country. I didn't know that, but I don't really care.

I didn't mention racism (#121246)
by HankP

because I don't think the Southern grievance against the Northern states has anything to do with racism. As far as the prevalence and strength of grievance, I find it's strongest in conservative areas in close proximity to liberal areas, but that's just my experience. It's kind of funny, too, because the reason conservatives live in close proximity to liberal cities is because that's where the jobs are.

--

I blame it all on the Internet

Links

Conservative
Liberal
Moderate/Mixed/Non-Partisan
Non-Political/Reference

Related Sites -

Polisci Applied (Aaron)
Intrepid Liberal Journal (Intrepid Liberal)
Obsidian Wings (Bird Dog)
Open Hand/Open Eye (locutas)
Red State (Bird Dog)
Swords Crossed (brendanm98)
Wagster Speaks (Wagster)
WatchingAmerica (BlaiseP)
The Social Pathologist (TSP)

Foreign Affairs -

Abu Aardvark
'Aqoul
American Footprints
Council on Foreign Relations
CSIS
Democracy Arsenal
Intel Dump
The Fourth Rail
War and Piece

Politics -

Ace of Spades HQ
Andrew Sullivan
Balloon Juice
Belgravia Dispatch
Captain's Quarters
Crooked Timber
Curmudgeonly & Skeptical
Daily Kos
Democracy Arsenal
Eschaton
Firedoglake
Glenn Greenwald
Global Guerrillas
Hugh Hewitt
Instapundit
Jawa Report
Lawyers, Guns and Money
Liberals Against Terror
Matt Yglesias
Michael J. Totten
Michelle Malkin
Moon of Alabama
New America
OxBlog
Patterico
Political Animal
Political Wire
Publius Pundit
QandO
Reality Based Community
Talking Points Memo
The Agitator
The Belmont Club
The Corner
Truman Project
Winds of Change.net

War -

Counterterrorism Blog
Iraq the Model
Jihad Watch
Small Wars Journal Blog

Economics and Business -

Angry Bear
Brad DeLong
Daniel Drezner
Mahalanobis
Marginal Revolution
Roubini Global Economics
The Big Picture

Science and Tech -

Bad Astronomy
New Scientist
Real Climate
Science Blogs
Scientific American
The Panda's Thumb

Legal -

Balkinization
Conglomerate
Ideoblog
Jurisdynamics
Law and Letters
Overlawyered
ProfessorBainbridge
ScotusBlog
Talk Left
The Becker-Posner Blog
Volokh Conspiracy

Sports -

Baseball Crank
Baseball Musings
Baseball Reference.com
ESPN.com
NFL.com
Only Baseball Matters
The Sports Economist

Books, Film and Music -

Amazon.com
Internet Movie Database
All Music Guide

News and Aggregators -

Asia Times
Boingboing
CNN
Digg
English Russia
Fark
Los Angeles Times
Memeorandum
MSNBC
Politico
Poynteronline
Slashdot
The New York Times
The Washington Post

References -

Wikipedia
Your Dictionary